How the two grades are built
Both grades are Pine Harbor constructs, not official ratings. Each turns the underlying taxes into a single 0–100 score (higher is friendlier) so states rank consistently, and both use the same A–F scale. They differ in what they count.
The retirement-tax grade answers a focused question: how hard does this state tax the money you draw in retirement and the wealth you pass on? It weighs income on withdrawals, Social Security, and estate/inheritance taxes — the levers most specific to retirees.
45
Income on withdrawals
Scaled by the top rate; full marks if retirement income is untaxed or there's no income tax.
15
Social Security
Full marks if benefits are exempt; reduced if the state taxes them.
40
Estate & inheritance
Full marks with neither tax; penalized more as the estate exemption falls.
The overall tax burden grade widens the lens to the taxes everyone pays regardless of income source — folding in property tax on your home and sales tax on your spending. It's the more realistic picture for a homeowner, and it changes several stories: a no-income-tax state with steep property taxes, or an income-friendly state with a high estate tax, both slip once everything is counted.
30
Income on withdrawals
Same idea, smaller share of the total.
8
Social Security
Exempt in all but eight states.
22
Property tax
Effective rate on owner-occupied homes — a fixed annual cost.
15
Sales tax
Combined state + average local rate on what you spend.
25
Estate & inheritance
Same legacy taxes, weighed against the everyday ones.
If your estate is comfortably below a state's exemption, read the income, Social Security, property, and sales columns first and weigh the legacy columns lightly. If it isn't, those columns may matter more than the rate on your next withdrawal. Property tax is shown as the effective rate — actual taxes paid as a share of home value — because headline "mill rates" aren't comparable across states with different assessment rules. Sales tax is the combined state and average local rate; your county may differ, and most states exempt or reduce tax on groceries and medicine.
What a tax table can't tell you
We stopped at taxes on purpose. Two of the biggest factors in where a retirement actually succeeds don't belong in a tax grade — and pretending they do would make the tool less honest, not more.
The first is healthcare. Access to good hospitals and specialists, Medicare Advantage plan availability, and the cost of supplemental coverage vary enormously — but they vary far more by county and city than by state, and the quality rankings that do exist disagree with one another. A statewide letter grade would flatten exactly the local detail that matters, so we'd rather you look at the specific communities you're considering than trust an average.
The second is cost of living. Housing, in particular, can dwarf every tax on this page: a lower tax bill in a high-housing-cost metro can still leave you worse off than a modestly-taxed state where your dollar stretches further. Groceries, utilities, insurance, and — for many retirees — the cost of being near family or the right airport all sit outside a tax comparison but often outrank it in the decision. The right way to weigh them is against your own budget and your own shortlist, not a national index.
Our take
Taxes are a real number, but they're a poor reason to uproot a life on their own. We've watched people chase a zero-income-tax headline into a state with punishing property taxes, a long flight from family, or a higher cost of living that quietly erased the savings.
The better use of a table like this is as a starting map. It tells you which levers your current state pulls hardest, where a move might genuinely help, and what to pressure-test before you sign anything. When a relocation does make sense, the tax win is usually the tie-breaker between two good options — not the reason by itself. If you're weighing a move, let's model your actual income mix, withdrawal sequence, and estate picture against both states before you decide.
Sources & notes
Reflects our understanding of state law as of July 2026. Primary sources: Tax Foundation (2026 State Individual Income Tax Rates and Brackets; State and Local Sales Tax Rates, January 2026; Estate and Inheritance Taxes by State) and Kiplinger, cross-checked against state departments of revenue. Effective property-tax rates are for owner-occupied homes, derived from U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey data (aggregate taxes paid as a share of home value; District of Columbia figure approximate). Includes 2025–2026 changes such as West Virginia's completed Social Security phase-out and Washington's estate-tax rollback (top rate returning to 20% with a $3M exemption for deaths on or after July 1, 2026, under ESB 6347). Income-tax figures are top marginal rates; sales-tax figures are combined state and average local rates; several exemptions and estate thresholds are indexed annually or subject to pending legislation. The two letter grades are illustrative educational constructs, not ratings of any state or of Pine Harbor. This is educational and not tax or legal advice — verify current figures with your tax professional and the relevant state before acting.
← All Insights